REPORT TO COUNCIL
SUBJECT
Title
Proposed Project: Forward a recommendation to the City Council on related items associated with residential off-street parking requirements:
a. Find that the proposed actions are exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.25(b)(11) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3); and,
b. Introduce an ordinance to amend the Sunnyvale Municipal Code Title 19 (Zoning) related to revising residential off-street parking requirements, including:
i) Repeal and Replace Chapter 19.46 Parking; and,
ii) Amend the following Chapters:
(1) 19.12 Definitions;
(2) 19.28 Downtown Specific Plan District;
(3) 19.35 Lawrence Station Area Plan District;
(4) 19.36 El Camino Real Specific Plan District; and,
(5) 19.78 Dual Urban Opportunity Housing
Location: Citywide
File #: 2022-7404
Applicant: City of Sunnyvale
Project Planner: Jeffrey Cucinotta, (408) 730-7424, jcucinotta@sunnyvale.ca.gov
Report
REPORT IN BRIEF
Sunnyvale’s residential off-street parking requirements are generally higher and more complex than some jurisdictions. Some requirements also need to be updated to reflect State laws.
The proposed ordinance to amend Title 19 (Zoning) of the Sunnyvale Municipal Code (SMC) (see Attachment 2) would: reduce and simplify minimum parking requirements for single-family, duplex, and multifamily housing; revise standards in certain specific plan areas; provide greater flexibility for tandem and compact parking; and, clarify requirements for loading spaces and unbundled parking. The changes are intended to reduce development costs, support housing production, and align local standards with State law.
The primary policy tradeoff is that providing less required on-site parking may reduce housing costs and free up land for housing and other uses but may also increase demand for on-street parking in some neighborhoods. The ordinance retains minimum guest parking requirements for multifamily development, while removing the additional parking requirement for multifamily projects with limited on-street parking.
The proposed ordinance does not comprehensively address on-street parking, nonresidential parking, bicycle parking, or monitoring and enforcement of transportation demand management programs. Staff identified these topics for potential future study that may require future Council direction.
Planning Commission’s recommendation will be forwarded to the City Council, which was originally scheduled to consider the updates on November 10, 2026. Instead, on November 10, 2026 City Council will consider continuing the item to a date certain; staff is recommending December 1, 2026.
BACKGROUND
The Council initiated this study in 2019 and refined its scope in 2022 to focus on residential parking requirements, comparisons with peer jurisdictions, and policies that warrant further study. On March 19, 2024, Council directed staff to conduct community outreach and prepare amendments to the Sunnyvale Municipal Code and applicable specific plans for future public hearings. The proposed ordinance implements that direction. See Attachments 3 and 4 for the legislative history and detailed scope of work.
EXISTING POLICY
A full list of relevant goals, policies, and strategies from the Council Policy Manual, General Plan (Land Use and Transportation Element [LUTE]; Housing Element), Climate Action Playbook, and Specific Plans (inclusive of Area Plan and Village Center Master Plan) is included in Attachment 5.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The action is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.25(b)(11) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3).
Public Resources Code Section 21080.25(b)(11) covers a planning decision carried out by a local agency to reduce or eliminate minimum parking requirements or institute parking maximums, remove or restrict parking, or implement transportation demand management requirements or programs.
CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3) is the “common sense exemption” that states that CEQA applies only to projects which have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is not subject to CEQA.
Future development projects that are subject to the requirements of the amended chapters will be environmentally evaluated on an individual basis.
DISCUSSION
This study completes the first segment of a broader review of Sunnyvale's parking policies. It focuses on off-street parking requirements for residential development, with the goal of simplifying standards, supporting housing production, and aligning local regulations with State law.
In this report, the term “specific plan” refers to adopted Specific Plans, Area Plans, and the Village Center Master Plan.
Purpose of this Study (Parking Policy/Management and Reform)
This study represents the City’s first step towards comprehensive citywide parking policy/management reform. Parking policy and management can affect neighborhood parking demand, transportation choices, emissions, housing affordability, development costs, and the amount of land available for housing and open space. Parking reform (one element of which includes reducing parking minimums) may help lower development costs and free up land. Attachment 6 includes a summary of some additional key industry highlights related to parking policy/management and reform.
Demographic and Vehicle Trends
City of Sunnyvale
Between 2019 and 2024, Sunnyvale's population increased by approximately 1%, occupied housing units increased by 7.5%, average household size declined from 2.71 to 2.54, and the share of occupied housing units with zero or one vehicle increased from 40% to 46.2%, as shown in Attachment 7. These trends do not directly establish the appropriate parking rates for individual housing types or neighborhoods; however, they underscore the importance of evaluating and updating the City’s residential parking requirements.
Comparison to Peer Jurisdictions
In comparing 2024 demographic and vehicle data from the U.S. Census Bureau for the City of Sunnyvale to the jurisdictions included in this study (all cities in Santa Clara County as well as certain other Bay Area jurisdictions), the following key observations emerge, as detailed in the tables and bar graphs in Attachment 8:
• Sunnyvale’s average household size of 2.54 persons is on the lower end of the range of 2.09 to 3.34 persons and is comparable to six other peer jurisdictions that also hover around 2.5 persons.
• Sunnyvale has a greater share of households with fewer than two vehicles than most of the jurisdictions surveyed. Seven percent of occupied housing units have no vehicle and 39.2 percent have one vehicle, for a combined 46.2 percent. Another 37.9 percent have two vehicles and 15.8 percent have three or more vehicles.
• A direct comparison to the City of Alameda, where mandatory parking minimums were repealed citywide in 2021, is noteworthy. In 2024, average household size in Sunnyvale was 2.54, compared to 2.53 for Alameda, and the percentage of occupied housing units with fewer than two cars was 46.2 in Sunnyvale and 48.9 in Alameda.
Outside of the Bay Area and in recent years, parking reform at the municipal level has become more common, including removing/decreasing parking mandates. Attachment 9 makes a comparison of the City of Sunnyvale to other mid-sized cities in other states that have recently removed parking mandates and have similar demographics or transit services. Most of the cities identified have a population ranging from around 100,000 to 200,000 and are less densely populated than Sunnyvale. Additionally, Sunnyvale is served by two Caltrain stations and seven VTA light rail stations within the City of Sunnyvale; many of the cities included are served by at least one train station.
State Laws Affecting Local Parking Requirements
In recent years, several California State bills have been adopted that limit local jurisdictions’ ability to set off-street parking standards for new developments. A brief summary of these bills is provided in Attachment 10 and they are discussed in more detail in the subsections that follow.
Among the State bills that are most relevant to this parking study, Assembly Bill (AB) 2097 prohibits local jurisdictions from imposing minimum parking requirements for qualifying developments within one-half mile of a major transit stop. AB 2553 further expanded the definition of major transit stop, increasing the areas in Sunnyvale where this restriction applies. These areas are shown on the map in Attachment 11.
AB 2097/2553 apply to both residential and non-residential developments, with limited exceptions for hotels and event centers. The bill does not:
• Exempt projects from meeting the City’s requirements for electric vehicle and accessible spaces,
• Prohibit developers from providing parking, or
• Restrict local jurisdictions from regulating parking design or management.
The proposed ordinance incorporates applicable State requirements and makes additional local policy changes. The following analysis focuses on the local standards Council can consider changing. A detailed summary of the relevant State laws is provided in Attachment 10
Proposed Revisions to Parking Count Requirements in the Zoning Code and Specific Plan Areas
Single/Two-Family Residential
Single- and two-family residential parking requirements apply in the zoning districts that permit residential uses, primarily R-1, R-0 and R-2, shown in the map in Attachment 11.
In comparing Sunnyvale’s requirements for single- and two-family dwellings to those of peer jurisdictions (including total required spaces as well as covered/uncovered requirements), two key takeaways (outlined in Attachment 12) are apparent:
• Sunnyvale’s residential parking requirements are higher than the jurisdictions surveyed, with four parking spaces per unit (two covered and two uncovered). Several jurisdictions surveyed require a total of two total spaces, while others vary their requirements based on factors such as the number of bedrooms, floor area, or zoning district.
• Uncovered parking requirements are uncommon among the jurisdictions surveyed. Of the jurisdictions included in the comparison, only Sunnyvale, Cupertino, and Monte Sereno require uncovered parking spaces, while the remaining jurisdictions surveyed have no separate uncovered parking requirement.
Required Parking Count: Based on City Council direction and a comparison of Sunnyvale’s requirements with those of peer jurisdictions, staff proposes reducing the overall minimum parking requirements for single-family and two-family dwellings, including lowering the amount of uncovered parking spaces required.
Existing and proposed minimum required off-street parking count is as follows:

Limited On-Street Parking: SMC Chapter 19.46 requires new single- or two-family dwellings with “limited” street parking to provide an additional 0.4 unassigned parking spaces per unit. However, the SMC does not objectively define what “limited” means. Staff has historically applied this code provision to new subdivisions where immediate property frontage (before subdividing) is void of on-street parking or has fewer than one parking space on the street per every two units being constructed.
The proposed updates revise the subjective terminology to include more objective thresholds and reduce the requirement from 0.4 to 0.25 additional unassigned spaces per unit.
Parking provisions for homes without adjacent on-street parking: Additionally, to address guest and service vehicle parking for single-family and duplex properties without adjacent parking on the public street, the update also includes a more flexible front yard area coverage requirement (increased from 50 percent [standard requirement] to 75 percent in applicable cases) without the need for a variance.
Required Parking Upgrade (AB 1308): SMC Chapter 19.46 (Parking) requires legal nonconforming single-family dwellings with fewer than two covered parking spaces to provide upgraded parking (i.e., ensure there are two covered parking spaces on site) if a proposed addition or remodel to the dwelling results in: four or more bedrooms; or, 1,800 square feet or more of floor area.
However, AB 1308 exempts additions and remodels with nonconforming parking from meeting the minimum covered parking requirement, provided the project remains within the applicable local maximum-size limitations, such as floor-area ratio, lot coverage, or height restrictions. The intent of the law is to prevent a modest home addition from triggering a requirement to construct additional garage or off-street parking.
The proposed update removes this requirement from SMC.
Multiple-Family Residential
The off-street parking counts for multiple family residential development (including required minimums and permitted maximums) apply to the zoning districts identified in the map in Attachment 11 and are discussed below. Attachment 13 provides a summary of applicable standards, including a comparison of State law (AB 2097 and State Density Bonus Law), citywide standards in SMC Chapter 19.46, and standards within specific plan areas.
State Density Bonus Law: The State Density Bonus Law (including both SB 1818 [2004] and AB 2345 [2020]) applies to qualifying multiple-family residential projects of five or more units that have sufficient set-aside for below market rate units. Most multiple-family residential projects in the City of Sunnyvale are eligible for the State Density Bonus program because the City’s affordable housing requirements meet or exceed the thresholds in the State law. The program establishes a maximum limit to the amount of off-street parking that local jurisdictions may impose, as shown in Attachment 13. Developers must specifically request the parking reductions available under the State Density Bonus program. Alternatively, when parking reductions are not requested, developers may provide more off-street parking, to the extent that the project does not conflict with any applicable parking maximums.
Required Parking Count: For multiple-family residential projects that do not qualify for the State Density Bonus program and are not located within one-half mile of a major transit stop or within a specific plan area, the following off-street parking requirements apply:
• Market Rate Housing: SMC Chapter 19.46 identifies minimum required off-street parking (covered/assigned and uncovered/unassigned) that ranges depending on the number of covered parking spaces provided (in a garage, carport, or parking structure) and bedroom count. This requirement requires multiple complicated steps in order to calculate applicable parking rates and is often difficult for developers to understand.
o When one covered/assigned parking space per unit is provided, a higher unassigned rate applies, and when two covered/assigned parking spaces per unit are provided, a slightly lower unassigned rate applies.
o The required combined covered/uncovered minimums range from 1.5-2.25 spaces for one-bedroom units to 2.15-2.65 spaces for four- or more bedroom units, and almost all unit types require at least 2 parking spaces as shown in Attachment 13
• Affordable Housing: Below market rate housing also has a lower minimum required off street parking count, as shown in Attachment 13.
• Guest Parking Spaces: SMC Chapter 19.46 does not explicitly require guest parking. However, staff often includes a condition of approval for new multiple-family residential developments that encourages at least 25 percent and no more than 75 percent of the provided unassigned parking spaces to be reserved for guest use only.
• Limited On-Street Parking: In addition to the minimum requirements stated above, SMC Chapter 19.46 allows the Community Development Department (CDD) director or approving body to require additional unassigned parking spaces beyond the minimum requirements for projects with “limited street parking.” However, this term is undefined, and there are no objective standards or rates for applying this provision.
Comparison to Peer Jurisdictions: Direct comparison of Sunnyvale’s requirements to other jurisdictions is challenging due to variation in product type, bedroom count, and zoning district. Sunnyvale’s requirements are further complicated because they depend on the number of proposed covered parking spaces. Sunnyvale’s requirement of at least two parking spaces per unit (for most unit types) is among the highest requirements of the jurisdictions assessed. Overall, it is clear that more complex and nuanced parking requirements across jurisdictions tend to correlate with higher minimum requirements. Attachment 14 provides a comparison of the parking requirements.
Proposed Changes:
• Minimum Required Off-Street Parking: The requirements for minimum required parking count have been consolidated/simplified and lowered, as shown in Attachments 2 and 13. The proposed revisions align with the State Density Bonus program rates and are also easier to interpret and enforce.
• Guest Parking Spaces: The minimum required guest parking shall be whichever is greater of the following:
o 0.25 spaces per dwelling unit; or,
o One space.
A definition for “guest parking” also has been added to SMC Chapter 19.12 (Definitions).
• Limited On-Street Parking: Remove this requirement for multiple-family residential developments.
Mixed-Use Development and Shared Parking
Most mixed-use development within Sunnyvale occurs within Specific Plan areas. Parking requirements for mixed-use developments are calculated by adding parking needs of each individual land use in the project, and mixed-use development projects with housing may also qualify for State Density Bonus parking reductions.
The City allows shared parking through a discretionary permit review and encourages it within specific plan areas. Under AB 894 (2023), qualifying developments may count underutilized parking on nearby properties towards their required parking, potentially reducing the need for dedicated parking on multifamily residential sites.
No changes are proposed for mixed-use development and shared parking provisions at this time. However, because this parking study does not address parking requirements for non-residential uses, staff recommends a more comprehensive parking study to assess shared parking for non-residential and other mixed-use development types, as discussed in Attachment 15.
Specific Plans
Residential off-street parking requirements within the City’s specific plan areas (boundaries shown in the map in Attachment 11) are already lower than the citywide requirements discussed above, including lower required minimums and also established permitted maximums. Attachment 13 summarizes the applicable standards, which includes a comparison of State law (AB 2097 and State Density Bonus Law) to citywide standards in SMC 19.46 Parking and in the specific plan areas stated below. Additional considerations relevant to certain specific plan areas are also noted below.
Proposed changes include revising residential off-street parking requirements to remove minimums and implement maximums for certain plan areas, as shown in Attachments 2 and 13:
• Downtown Specific Plan: Remove minimum and establish maximums.
• Lawrence Station Area Plan: Remove minimums.
• El Camino Real Precise Plan: Remove minimums, align maximums to other specific plan rates.
• Moffett Park Specific Plan: No changes; existing maximums and transportation demand management approach remain.
• Village Center Master Plan: No changes.
• Peery Park Specific Plan: No changes; applicable residential parking requirements default to SMC Chapter 19.46, and a separate plan update is currently underway.
• 101/Lawrence Site Specific Plan: No changes; the plan area is fully built out and redevelopment is unlikely in the near term.
• Lakeside Specific Plan: No changes; the plan area is fully built out and redevelopment is unlikely in the near term.
Other Parking Changes
The proposed ordinance also makes changes to other residential parking standards by increasing flexibility and simplifying development requirements in the following ways:
• Single Room Occupancy (SRO) Facilities: Remove minimum parking requirements for residents, per Housing Element implementation item Program H23.
• Tandem Parking Spaces:
o Single-Family, Two-Family and Multiple-Family (Townhomes only): Tandem parking will be allowed by right for all units, with each pair of spaces assigned to the same unit for two-family and townhome units
o All other Multiple-Family Residential: No changes are proposed.
• Compact Parking Spaces: Increase the compact parking allowance to up to 20 percent of the total provided parking spaces for multiple-family residential developments with ten or more parking spaces
• Loading Spaces: Require at least one off-street loading space for projects with 10 to 100 units and at least two spaces for projects with over 100 units.
These items are summarized in Attachment 15.
Parking Count Requirements with No Proposed Changes
Parking categories listed below do not include any proposed changes because they fall out of the scope of this parking study or because State law limits a local jurisdiction’s ability to impose parking requirements:
• Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs)
• Dual Urban Opportunity (DUO) Housing Units
• Mobile Home Parks
• Assisted Living Units
• Bicycle Parking: See Attachment 16 for potential future action items related to bicycle parking.
These items are summarized in Attachment 15.
Other Parking Management Strategies
Apart from required parking count, this parking study also assessed the following off-street residential parking requirements:
Transportation Demand Management
As mentioned in Attachment 4, City Council requested staff to consider relying on Transportation Demand Management (TDM) in lieu of parking minimums. TDM is a crucial tool for providing travel options and reducing single-occupancy vehicle trips. Some potential co-benefits resulting from TDM policies may include less land dedicated to parking, lower development costs, reduced emissions, and increased affordability, among other benefits.
The City has two separate Transportation Demand Management (TDM) programs: one for multiple-family residential development and another for office, research and development, and industrial developments. This parking study is limited to reviewing the multiple-family residential TDM program.
In the City of Sunnyvale, participation in the TDM program is required for all multiple-family residential developments with ten or more dwelling units. Projects can reach compliance through the following program categories/activities:
• Provision of an allocated amount of below market rate units;
• Proximity to transit (major transit routes/stops), car/bicycle share hub, and/or commercial land uses (shopping center or multi-tenant commercial development);
• Provision of physical improvements (bicycle facilities, wayfinding station, or other access improvements); and,
• Provision of ongoing services: transit memberships (Caltrain Go Pass, VTA EcoPass, car/bicycle share, etc.) and on-site TDM coordination and communication.
The Moffett Park Specific Plan is the only plan area in the City of Sunnyvale with specific TDM strategies that are more comprehensive than those in the citywide multiple-family residential TDM program, including participation in a Transportation Management Association (TMA), targeted trip reduction goals, and a more robust list of eligible program categories/activities. The TMA is intended to oversee and manage the MPSP TDM program.
The City of Sunnyvale does not currently have a program in place to help facilitate ongoing monitoring, reporting, and enforcement of the TDM program categories that involve provision of ongoing services.
Some nearby jurisdictions such as San Francisco and San José require compliance with the TDM program in lieu of providing minimum required off street parking. Other TDM programs include both mandatory and optional program compliance items.
Proposed Changes: None at this time. Staff acknowledges the need for a comprehensive review and update to the multiple-family residential TDM program, including assessing program effectiveness alongside reducing parking minimums, as well as establishing procedures for monitoring, reporting, and enforcement. However, as discussed in the previous sections, the proposed reductions to residential off-street parking requirements in the ordinance would be separate from and would not depend on the TDM program measures. A full TDM program review would require additional resources in order to determine adequate potential appropriate changes. See Attachment 16 for more information.
Unbundled Parking (AB 1317):
Unbundled parking allows residents to lease or purchase parking separately from their housing. This can reduce housing costs for households that need fewer parking spaces. However, it may also shift some parking demand to nearby streets if residents choose not to pay for on-site parking.
AB 1317 requires all new multiple family residential rental developments with 16 or more units to unbundle parking. The proposed ordinance would update the Sunnyvale Municipal Code to reflect State requirements. Staff also identifies monitoring, reporting, and enforcement as potential future work.
SMC 19.12 Definitions
The proposed ordinance updates in Attachment 2 also include revisions to various definitions of parking and other zoning terms. Other definitions have been relocated from different subsections of Chapter 19.46 to Chapter 19.12 Definitions.
Potential Future Parking Study Items
As previously stated, this study is limited to assessing off-street parking requirements for residential developments. It does not address requirements for non-residential developments or for on-street parking. However, staff recognizes that changes to residential parking requirements on private property should also be considered alongside the requirements for other land use and development types and within the public right of way and in public parking lots and districts. For this reason, a summary of potential future parking study items is included in Attachment 16. These items are not included in the staff recommendation but could be considered in the future if directed by City Council.
FISCAL IMPACT
The proposed changes to parking requirements in the SMC as described in this report will have no direct or immediate fiscal impact on the City.
However, reducing minimum required parking rates for residential developments can create several financial benefits for residents, property owners, and developers. Some of these benefits include lower permitting and construction costs (overall and also per dwelling unit), more efficient use of land (the amount of land devoted to parking vehicles becomes available dwelling units, amenities, open space, etc.), and reduced long-term operating and maintenance costs
The financial benefits may vary depending on location and project type. In lower density areas of the City with abundant free parking, reducing requirements may have a more limited impact, while in transit-rich areas, the potential cost savings could be substantially more, particularly when no structured or underground parking is needed.
PUBLIC CONTACT
Community Outreach Meeting
City staff hosted an online community outreach meeting on September 30, 2026. Public notice was posted in the September 18th publication of the City Manager’s Report, Update Sunnyvale. In addition, an email blast was sent out to over 400 individual subscribers to the project website as well as to all Neighborhood Associations in the City.
There were nine members of the public present at the outreach meeting. Meeting attendees asked questions and provided feedback about the impacts of off-street parking requirements on on-street parking, guest parking, tandem parking, RV parking, and the relationship between use of on-street areas for vehicle parking and for other users such as cyclists. A summary of public comment received is provided below.
Public Comment
As of the date of publication of this staff report, the City has received feedback via email from eight members of the public, which is provided in Attachment 17. In addition, a brief summary of the feedback received (including during the community outreach meeting and separately/in writing) is provided below.
1. Minimum Required Off-Street Parking: Moderately decrease parking minimums overall, while maintaining parking minimums in areas without sufficient public transit access/alternatives.
2. On-Street Parking:
a. Reducing off-street parking requirements will increase demand for on-street parking, which could conflict with the needs of cyclists and active transportation advocates.
b. Expand the study to include on-street parking considerations/requirements and current neighborhood conditions.
3. Guest Parking: Decrease the minimum required guest parking to 10 percent of the unassigned parking count.
4. ADU parking: Allow more flexibility when a new ADU is proposed in a neighborhood with limited on-street parking; consider some type of exception or alternative standards.
5. Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Commission (BPAC): Consult with BPAC as the study issue progresses.
6. Bicycle parking:
a. Non-residential: Unbundle bicycle parking requirement from the vehicle parking requirement.
b. Residential: Increase the bicycle parking requirement.
c. Design: Update design standards, using the VTA Bicycle Technical Guidelines for direction.
7. RV Parking: Concerns about on-street RV parking impacting visibility for cyclists and children.
8. Neighborhood Association Participation: One neighborhood association requested City staff to attend a regular meeting to present and discuss the study findings.
Notice of Planning Commission and City Council Public Hearings
The notice of the City Council and Planning Commission public hearings as well as availability of the staff report and agenda were made available in the following ways:
• Notice published in the Sunnyvale Sun newspaper on October 2, 2026
• Posted on the City of Sunnyvale’s website (see Attachment 3)
• Email to subscribers to the project website
• Agenda posted on the City’s official notice bulletin board.
• Agenda and this report are available at the City Hall reception desk located on the first floor of City Hall at 456 W. Olive Avenue (during normal business hours).
ALTERNATIVES
1) Alternative 1: Forward a recommendation to the City Council on related items associated with residential off-street parking requirements:
a) Find that the proposed actions are exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.25(b)(11) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3); and,
b) Introduce an ordinance to amend the Sunnyvale Municipal Code Title 19 (Zoning) related to revising residential off-street parking requirements, including:
i) Repeal and Replace Chapter 19.46 Parking; and,
ii) Amend the following Chapters:
(1) 19.12 Definitions;
(2) 19.28 Downtown Specific Plan District;
(3) 19.35 Lawrence Station Area Plan District;
(4) 19.36 El Camino Real Specific Plan District; and,
(5) 19.78 Dual Urban Opportunity Housing
2) Alternative 2: Alternative 1 with modifications
3) Alternative 3: Take no action on residential off-street parking requirements and instead provide direction on desired changes
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Recommendation
Alternative 1: Forward a recommendation to the City Council on related items associated with residential off-street parking requirements:
• Find that the proposed actions are exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.25(b)(11) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3); and,
• Introduce an ordinance to amend the Sunnyvale Municipal Code Title 19 (Zoning) related to revising residential off-street parking requirements, including:
o Repeal and Replace Chapter 19.46 Parking; and,
o Amend the following Chapters:
§ 19.12 Definitions;
§ 19.28 Downtown Specific Plan District;
§ 19.35 Lawrence Station Area Plan District;
§ 19.36 El Camino Real Specific Plan District; and,
§ 19.78 Dual Urban Opportunity Housing
JUSTIFICATION FOR RECOMMENDATION
Reasonable reductions in the amount of required parking not only assists property owners, but also contributes to decreased housing costs, increases the number of available units, avoids an oversupply of parking spaces, reduces impervious surface area, discourages higher rates of vehicle ownership, and promotes climate-friendly modes of transportation such as walking, bicycling, carpooling, and taking transit. These reductions are also aligned with the City’s various goals, policies, and strategies for parking and housing development.
Adopting the proposed changes included in Alternative 1 would allow property owners of single/two-family dwellings to more easily expand and remodel without the constraint of accommodating a total of four parking spaces onsite. Reducing the area dedicated to parking allows more space available for ADUs and extended families living together in one house. It also would align the City’s standards with those of other jurisdictions within Santa Clara County and throughout the Bay Area.
The recommended reduction in minimum requirements for multifamily developments would have a limited impact overall, since reduced parking requirements are already in place for certain Specific Plans, areas within one half mile of transit, and projects utilizing density bonus reduced parking allowances. The primary tradeoff for such a reduction is likely to result in fewer unassigned/guest parking spaces onsite.
Levine Act
LEVINE ACT
The Levine Act (Gov. Code Section 84308) prohibits city officials from participating in certain decisions regarding licenses, permits, and other entitlements for use if the official has received a campaign contribution of more than $500 from a party, participant, or agent of a party or participant in the previous 12 months. The Levine Act is intended to prevent financial influence on decisions that affect specific, identifiable persons or participants. For more information see the Fair Political Practices Commission website: www.fppc.ca.gov/learn/pay-to-play-limits-and-prohibitions.html
An “X” in the checklist below indicates that the action being considered falls under a Levine Act category or exemption:
SUBJECT TO THE LEVINE ACT
___ Land development entitlements
___ Other permit, license, or entitlement for use
___ Contract or franchise
EXEMPT FROM THE LEVINE ACT
___ Competitively bid contract*
___ Labor or personal employment contract
___ Contract under $50,000 or non-fiscal
___ Contract between public agencies
X General policy and legislative actions
* "Competitively bid" means a contract that must be awarded to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder.
Staff
Prepared by: Jeffrey Cucinotta, Senior Planner
Reviewed by: Aastha Vashist, Principal Planner
Reviewed by: Trudi Ryan, Director of Community Development
Reviewed by: Connie Verceles, Assistant City Manager
Approved by: Tim Kirby, City Manager
ATTACHMENTS
1. Reserved for Report to Council
2. Draft Ordinance
3. Links to Project Background and Website
4. Summary of 2024 Council Motion (Scope of Work)
5. Parking Policies, Goals, and Objectives
6. Key Industry Highlights of Parking Policy/Management and Reform
7. Demographic and Vehicle Trends (City of Sunnyvale, 2019-2024)
8. Demographic and Vehicle Comparison (City of Sunnyvale and Other Peer Jurisdictions, 2024)
9. Mid-Sized Cities that Recently Removed Parking Mandates
10. List of Recent California State Laws that Have Impacted Local Parking Requirements
11. Map of Zoning Districts, Specific Plan Areas, and Major Transit Stop Zones
12. Single/Two-Family Residential Comparison to Peer Jurisdictions
13. Current and Proposed Multiple-Family Residential Off-Street Parking Counts
14. Multiple-Family Residential Comparison to Peer Jurisdictions
15. Other Parking Changes and Parking Count Requirements with No Proposed Changes
16. List of Potential Future Parking Study Items
17. Public Comment Letters/Emails