Legislation Details

File #: 20-0864   
Type: Report to Council Status: Passed
Meeting Body: City Council
On agenda: 12/1/2020
Title: Adopt a Resolution Amending the City's Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay to (1) Update Pay Rates for Casual/Temporary Classifications to Reflect the January 1, 2021 Sunnyvale Minimum Wage, (2) Increase the Councilmember and Mayor Stipend Amounts pursuant to City Charter section 605; (3) Change Four Classification Titles in the Department of Library and Recreation Services; (4) Implement Changes to Casual/Temporary Classifications; and (5) Implement Minor Administrative Changes
Attachments: 1. Resolution with Redline Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay

REPORT TO COUNCIL

SUBJECT

Title

Adopt a Resolution Amending the City's Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay to (1) Update Pay Rates for Casual/Temporary Classifications to Reflect the January 1, 2021 Sunnyvale Minimum Wage, (2) Increase the Councilmember and Mayor Stipend Amounts pursuant to City Charter section 605; (3) Change Four Classification Titles in the Department of Library and Recreation Services; (4) Implement Changes to Casual/Temporary Classifications; and (5) Implement Minor Administrative Changes

Report

 

BACKGROUND

This Report presents for Council consideration a resolution amending the City’s Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay in accordance with Section 3.80.040 of the Sunnyvale Municipal Code to update the pay rates for applicable classifications to reflect the 2021 minimum wage of $16.30, and increase the Councilmember and Mayor stipend amount for 2021 in accordance with City Charter Section 605, which provides for annual cost of living adjustments based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) 

 

Further, the Department of Human Resources initiated a periodic process of presenting to Council recommended updates to the Salary Resolution and the associated Schedule of Pay. The purpose for this practice is to have a regular schedule for new requests and changes due to Memorandum of Understanding (MOUs) or other policy requirements to come before Council for approval. The last update was completed in December 2019.

 

The Department of Library and Community Services changed its name to the Department of Library and Recreation Services effective September 1, 2020. Among other administrative changes, this update reflects changes to four classification titles related to that name change.

 

EXISTING POLICY

Council Policy 7.3.1 Legislative Management - Goals and Policies - Goal 7.3D: Maintain a quality workforce, consistent with state and federal laws, City Charter, and adopted policies in order to assure that City services are provided in an effective, efficient, and high quality manner.

 

Council Policy 7.3.1 Legislative Management - Goals and Policies - Policy 7.3D.1: Maintain a recruitment and selection process that ensures a highly competent workforce.

 

City Charter Section 605. Compensation: Annually on January 1, the compensation of the Council and Mayor shall increase by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the preceding October’s 12-month rolling average of the Consumer Price Index - Urban (CPI-U).

 

Sunnyvale Municipal Code Section 3.80.040 (Minimum Wage)

 

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW

The action being considered does not constitute a “project” with the meaning of the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15378(b)(4) in that is a fiscal activity that does not involve any commitment to any specific project which may result in a potential significant impact on the environment, and section 15378(b)(5) in that it is a governmental organizational or administrative activity that will not result in direct or indirect changes in the environment.

 

DISCUSSION

This report presents for Council consideration a resolution amending the City’s Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay. Below is an explanatory list of the recommended changes with an effective date of December 27, 2020.

 

Incorporate 2021 Minimum Wage and Council Stipend Rates in the Schedule of Pay

 

As of January 1, 2021, the City of Sunnyvale minimum wage will increase from $16.05 to $16.30 per hour. There are approximately 80 Casual/Temporary employees who will be impacted by this change.

 

For calendar year 2021, the Councilmember stipend will be $2,693.31 per month and the Mayor stipend will be $3,591.09 per month, consistent with City Charter section 605, which provides for annual cost of living increases based on CPI-U.

 

Effective date of these new rates will be the start of the pay period inclusive of January 1, 2021, which is December 27, 2020.

 

Classification Title Changes from Community Services to Recreation Services

 

As of September 1, 2020, the Department of Library and Community Services (LCS) changed its name to the Department of Library and Recreation Services (LRS). In alignment with the department name change, staff recommends changing four classification titles as listed below.

 

Current Classification Title

New Classification Title

Community Services Coordinator 1/2

Recreation Services Coordinator 1/2

Community Services Manager

Recreation Services Manager

Director of Library & Community Services

Director of Library & Recreation Services

Superintendent of Community Services

Superintendent of Recreation Services

 

Changes to the Casual/Temporary Schedule of Pay

 

The City created generic classification titles for Casual and Seasonal employees in 2014 to differentiate Casual classifications from classifications represented by a bargaining unit.  Regardless of the classification title, CalPERS requires that employees be paid based on a publicly available pay schedule and must receive compensation that is the same as other employees performing the same work.  The Department of Human Resources manually evaluates each casual/temporary pay rate when changes are made to the pay rate of regular employees performing comparable duties. In an effort to further simplify the Casual/Temporary classifications and Schedule of Pay before implementation of the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software, the following changes are proposed. The proposed new schedule of pay, which reflects the same pay rates for regular employees represented by bargaining units and temporary (formerly called casual) employees employed on a part-time limited assignment basis, will replace the current portion of the Schedule of Pay that has distinct titles and pay rates Casual/Temporary classifications. These changes will allow for accurate appointment to classifications based on job duties, offer higher transparency, enhance recruitment competitiveness, and ensure CalPERS compliance.

 

1)                     Eliminate generic Casual/Temporary classifications and create a schedule of pay for temporary assignments that aligns with existing job descriptions and pay rates for regular classifications. The following classifications have very broad job descriptions and perform job duties comparable to other City regular classifications.

•                     Casual Clerical 2/3/4

•                     Casual Executive 1/2/3

•                     Casual Librarian

•                     Casual Library Specialist 1/2/3

•                     Casual Management 1/2/3

•                     Casual Paraprofessional 1/2/3

•                     Casual Professional - Registered/Certified 1/2/3

•                     Casual Professional 1/2/3/4

•                     Casual Service Maintenance 2/3/4

•                     Casual Skilled Craft 1/2

•                     Casual Staff Support 2/3

•                     Casual Technical 1/2/3

 

The proposed changes will remove the above classifications from the Schedule of Pay. Instead, employment of Casual/Temporary employees will be based on similar job duties to the regular classification and pay rate. There will be exceptions when a regular classification is not available for Casual/Temporary employment (e.g., sworn public safety classifications (Public Safety Officer, Lieutenant, Captain and Deputy Chief), in-training classifications, and part-time and Confidential with the same classifications in the Sunnyvale Employees’ Association/IFPTE Local 21 (SEA).

 

CalPERS requires compensation paid to retirees in post-retirement employment not be more or less than the pay range of other employees performing comparable duties. The proposed changes will ensure the City compensates retirees in post-retirement employment the same as regular and casual/temporary employees performing comparable duties.

 

With the proposed changes, Casual/Temporary employees will receive annual across-the-board increases when negotiated changes are made to the salary schedule for represented classifications.  There is no change to benefits or representation of Casual/Temporary employees. Casual/Temporary employees are not represented by a bargaining unit and do not receive City paid benefits, except for Casual sick leave and applicable retirement (e.g., Public Agency Retirement Services Alternative Retirement System).

 

The proposed changes will result in a modest pay rate increase (average 2.5%) for approximately 86 incumbent Casual/Temporary employees.

 

2)                     Job code updates. To reduce duplicative maintenance and aid in data cleansing for the ERP implementation, Casual and Seasonal job codes of the same classification will be consolidated. The proposed changes will not result in pay rate changes for incumbent Casual/Temporary employees.

 

3)                     Streamline the remaining Casual/Temporary classifications on the Schedule of Pay. The City does not have regular employees performing comparable duties for several Casual/Temporary classifications, listed in the table below. To simplify and modernize the classification titles, and offer better control and flexibility on pay rates, the following actions are recommended. The proposed changes will not result in pay rate changes for incumbent Casual/Temporary employees.

 

•                     Remove the word “Casual” from classification titles.

•                     Reduce multiple-level classifications into fewer levels.

•                     Merge similar classifications into one classification title.

•                     Replace pay steps 1 to 6 with a minimum and maximum pay range.

•                     Increase maximum pay ranges slightly to allow room for upcoming minimum wage changes and future inflation.

 

Current Classification Title

New Classification Title

Casual Capital Project Assistant 1/2/3  Casual Grant Assistant 1/2/3/4  Casual Special Project Assistant 1/2/3/4

Project/Grant Assistant 1/2

Casual Program Assistant Casual Recreation Attendant  Casual Recreation Specialist

Recreation Assistant

Casual Assistant Pool Manager

Assistant Pool Manager

Casual Crime Prevention Assistant

Crime Prevention Assistant

Casual Intermittent Recreation 1/2/3

Remove

Casual Lifeguard/Swim Instructor 2 (WSI Certified)

Lifeguard/Swim Instructor

Casual NOVA Youth Worker

NOVA Youth Worker

Casual Pool Manager

Pool Manager

Casual Public Safety Cadet

Public Safety Cadet

Casual Recreation Instructor/Official 2/3/4/5/6/7

Recreation Instructor 1/2 Recreation Instructor (Expert)

Casual Senior Case Manager 1/2/3

Case Manager

Casual Site Lead

Recreation Specialist

Casual Sports Official

Sports Official

Casual Theatre Technician

Recreation Technician

Casual Unskilled Laborer 2

Laborer

Intern 1/2

Intern

 

4)                     Create a new Casual/Temporary classification of Public Safety Technical Professional. The Department of Public Safety hires Casual/Temporary personnel requiring the understanding and background of public safety sworn positions. These assignments are unique and have specific job requirements that need a dedicated Casual/Temporary classification. The proposed change will create a new Casual/Temporary classification of Public Safety Technical Professional, with a pay range similar to the Public Safety Officer/Lieutenant pay range.  This proposed change will not result in pay rate changes for incumbent Casual/Temporary employees.

 

Changes to the Salary Resolution

 

Proposed updates to the Salary Resolution include changes to the Administrative Leave and Training Assistance benefits and makes minor administrative updates consistent with Memoranda of Understanding (MOUs) or other policy requirements.

 

1)                     Updates to Section 1.000 and Section 5.746. Reference of Casual/Temporary employees in the Salary Resolution is no longer identified by a separate pay category. Casual/Temporary employees were formerly identified as Pay Category H (unclassified recreation employees) and I (unclassified casual, seasonal and special project employees). Category J, Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA), is the remaining pay category describing a Casual/Temporary subcategory, and it will be removed as part of data cleansing.

 

2)                     Changes to Section 3.900 and 3.910 - Administrative Leave for Management and Confidential Employees. To be consistent with the administrative leave of the Sunnyvale Managers Association, leave entitlement of unrepresented management and Confidential employees for new hires or promotions from another bargaining unit will be changed from receiving the full 50 or 40 hours per year of administrative leave after 13 pay periods respectively to a pro-rated accrual based on the pay period of hire/promotion.

 

3)                     Changes to Section 5.300 - Training Assistance. Remove the Public Safety Cadet and Crime Prevention Assistant from eligibility for the training assistance benefit. This benefit is expended from a centralized pool of funds for Citywide eligible regular employees. The Public Safety Cadet and Crime Prevention Assistant are Casual/Temporary employees and their eligibility in this program reduces available funds for regular employees.

 

4)                     Removal of language that is duplicated in applicable Memorandum of Understanding (MOUs). The following sections are recommended for clean-up in the Salary Resolution as the language materially duplicates language contained in applicable MOUs:

•                     Section 5.506 - City Contribution. Dental Insurance.

•                     Section 5.507 - City Contribution. Vision Insurance.

•                     Section 5.515 - City Contribution. Cafeteria Benefits Plan.

•                     Section 5.520 - Maximum City Contribution. Health Insurance.

 

5)                     Revisions to Section 7.110 - Management Control Points and Salary Ranges. Simplify the language without material changes.

 

6)                     Updates to Section 8.000 - Casual/Temporary Pay Rate Assignments and Step Increase. With the proposed changes to the Casual/Temporary classifications, pay rates for Casual/Temporary classifications are presented in both pay steps (if assignment is based on a regular classification) or minimum/maximum pay ranges (if assignment does not have regular classifications performing comparable duties). Updates to the Salary Resolution clarify that merit increase is in one step or a 5% increment, depending on the classification. Eligibility for step or merit increases remain the same with no changes to current practice.

 

7)                     Minor housekeeping clean-up.

 

FISCAL IMPACT

Casual classifications are temporary, and the number of hours worked can vary. Therefore, specific departmental impacts will depend on the number of casual/temporary employees and hours worked. Departments that employ casual workers are expected to manage to their operating budget by absorbing cost increases or adjusting casual hours to meet budget. Further, Library and Recreation Services has the largest annual casual budget at approximately $1.3M (excluding temporary budget reductions pursuant to Budget Supplement 2 this year) and their casual salary costs are minimally impacted by the casual classification and rate changes.

 

Annual minimum wage and City Council stipend increase requirements are included in the long-term financial plans. The potential impact to departments is an average 2.5% increase in casual/temporary salary costs and up to $1.0M across all funds over twenty years as a result of the casual/temporary classification and rate changes, though as stated, departments are expected to manage casual employee costs to meet budget. Finance and Human Resources staff will continue to evaluate use of casual/temporary employees during the regular course of budget development.

 

PUBLIC CONTACT

Public contact was made by posting the Council agenda on the City's official-notice bulletin board outside City Hall, Sunnyvale Public Library and Department of Public Safety. In addition, the agenda and report are available at the Office of the City Clerk and on the City's website.

 

ALTERNATIVES

1.                     Adopt a Resolution Amending the City's Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay to (1) Update Pay Rates for Casual/Temporary Classifications to Reflect the January 1, 2021 Sunnyvale Minimum Wage, (2) Increase the Councilmember and Mayor Stipend Amounts pursuant to City Charter Section 605; (3) Change Four Classification Titles in the Department of Library and Recreation Services; (4) Implement Changes to Casual/Temporary Classifications; and (5) Implement Minor Administrative Changes

2.                     Do not adopt a Resolution Amending the City's Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay to (1) Update Pay Rates for Casual/Temporary Classifications to Reflect the January 1, 2021 Sunnyvale Minimum Wage, (2) Increase the Councilmember and Mayor Stipend Amounts pursuant to City Charter Section 605; (3) Change Classification Titles in the Department of Library and Recreation Services; (4) Implement Changes to Casual/Temporary Classifications; and (5) Implement Minor Administrative Changes

 

 

 

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

Recommendation

Alternative: 1. Adopt a Resolution Amending the City's Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay to (1) Update Pay Rates for Casual/Temporary Classifications to Reflect the January 1, 2021 Sunnyvale Minimum Wage, (2) Increase the Councilmember and Mayor Stipend Amounts pursuant to City Charter Section 605; (3) Change Four Classification Titles in the Department of Library and Recreation Services; (4) Implement Changes to the Casual/Temporary Classifications; and (5) Implement Minor Administrative Changes.

 

Staff

Prepared by: Vienne Choi, Term-Limited Human Resources Manager

Reviewed by: Tina Murphy, Director, Human Resources

Reviewed by: Teri Silva, Assistant City Manager

Approved by: Kent Steffens, City Manager

 

ATTACHMENTS 

1.                     Resolution with Redline Salary Resolution and Schedule of Pay