REPORT TO COUNCIL
SUBJECT
Title
Universal Basic Income Study Issue Follow Up (Information Only)
Report
BACKGROUND
In January 2022, the City Council sponsored Study Issue (SI) 22-07 - Evaluate a Pilot Program for Universal Basic Income (UBI) Including Potential Funding Sources. While the Study Issue was ranked by the Council, staff drew the line above the study issue for various reasons. Due to this action, SI 22-07 will be deferred for consideration until 2023.
On March 22, 2022, Councilmember Din requested further information regarding what would be needed, financially and/or staff support, to not defer SI 22-07 (UBI) and be able to begin work during FY 2022/23.
DISCUSSION
Study Issue 22-07 was prepared with the assumption it would be completed in-house without need for consultant support therefore a $0 budget was identified in the study issue. However, the line was drawn above this study issue because of limited staff capacity in the Community Development Department and Housing Division during 2022 as there are several high profile and time sensitive projects underway.
While hiring a consultant could allow this item to be studied at a faster pace, significant staff time is still needed for outreach (the most critical component of this study), management of the consultant, review of all prepared documents, and analysis of the outreach results by the Community Development Department, Finance Department, Office of the City Attorney and Office of the City Manager. A conceptual scope of work for this study would include items such as:
• Outreach (stakeholders, community, listening sessions, potential program operation agency interviews, etc.),
• Research potential funding source(s) (state, local, donations, etc.),
• Identify appropriate term length of pilot program,
• Research existing case studies and lessons learned from other cities,
• Identify success criteria,
• Identify program participation population (critical component of outreach),
• Identify implementation strategies and oversight of program,
• Identify level of City involvement and staffing needs for ongoing program.
An estimated consultant cost for a typical project of this size would be approximately $100,000; however, due to the unique nature of the study, costs could be greater as a specialized consultant may be needed. Hiring a consultant would require staff to prepare a Request for Proposals (RFP) and conduct a competitive application process, which averages six to eight months from staff preparation of an RFP to contract award. While existing housing staff availability to prepare this study in house will increase in mid-2023 as other time sensitive activities are completed, a new term limited Housing Programs Analyst in CDD could also meet the need of this study and allow staff to conduct this work in house, and potentially lead future program implementation based on the outcome of the study. The cost for a two-year, term limited Housing Programs Analyst is approximately $290,000. Due to numerous positions in the city currently in the recruitment process and the potential of multiple positions becoming unfrozen, it is uncertain how much time it could take to find someone to fill a term-limited position, likely several months. UBI programs are very new and will require more time than an average study issue from senior staff (Housing Officer, Directors, City Attorney, City Manager), even with consultant support. With so many other initiatives underway for 2022 it would be challenging to devote the necessary time to study this potential new program without cutting into the time spent on current operations and projects.
Community organizations such as Sunnyvale Community Services have expressed interest in sharing data and supporting staff with this study. This information would be helpful, however it would not complete all the required actions of this study. Staff would need to take the lead to hold significant community outreach during this study issue to ensure any program options identify: the full range of need/demand; the correct population to serve; and a sustainable funding source that can meet the community’s needs during a pilot program - and potentially longer. No two cities are the same, and while cities such as Stockton and Mountain View have or are underway on UBI programs, a one size fits all model is not recommended with this type of program to try and expedite study results.
PUBLIC CONTACT
Public contact was made by posting the Council agenda on the City's official-notice bulletin board outside City Hall, at the Sunnyvale Public Library and in the Department of Public Safety Lobby. In addition, the agenda and report are available at Office of the City Clerk, and on the City's website.
Staff
Prepared by: Jenny Carloni, Housing Officer
Reviewed by: Trudi Ryan, Director, Community Development
Reviewed by: Teri Silva, Assistant City Manager
Approved by: Kent Steffens, City Manager